Art Market 2024 and Beyond - How to Adjust? - Fall 2024
The art market has experienced a significant downturn following the 2024 U.S. presidential election, continuing a trend of decline that began earlier in the year. Several factors have contributed to this slide. These changes in buyer preferences have reshaped the art market landscape, forcing adaptations from all players in the industry. While presenting challenges, particularly for emerging artists and speculative investments, these shifts have also created new opportunities and potentially a more stable, mature market in the long run.
Economic and Political Factors
The art market contraction can be attributed to a combination of economic and political factors. Macroeconomic challenges included high interest rates, inflation, and political instability have created a challenging environment for the art market. There has been post-election uncertainty. Historically, stock market returns have been lower in the 12 months following a presidential election, with a higher likelihood of recession during this period. This economic uncertainty appears to have spilled over into the art market resulting in reduced high-end sales and a slowdown in turnover at the high end of the market. The persistent high interest rates have made borrowing more expensive and reduced liquidity in the market. Ongoing inflation has decreased purchasing power and made collectors more cautious about spending. The ongoing wars in Ukraine and the Middle East, as well as tensions with China, have created uncertainty and removed some buyers from the market.
Market Performance
The art market's performance has been notably weak showing global sales declin as indicated by art market sales falling by 4% in 2023 to an estimated $65 billion. This downward trend has continued into 2024 with auction sales droping During the first half of the year. Auction sales fell to $5.05 billion, which was nearly a 30% decline from the same period in the previous year. More than a dozen galleries in New York have closed over the past 12 months, including some prominent blue-chip players'
Buyer Behavior
The market downturn has affected buyer behavior in several ways. Speculators who entered the art market during the pandemic are now exiting, often selling works at significant losses. Some major collectors are now shopping for much cheaper art, with one example cited of a collector looking for $500 pieces at antiques stores and some buyers are delaying payments for purchases made earlier in the year. More cautious spending: High-net-worth individuals have become more conservative in their art investments, particularly for high-priced artworks. Shift towards quality and longevity: Collectors are adopting a more discerning approach, focusing on the personal enjoyment of art rather than speculative buys. There's a trend towards collecting works by both well-known and lesser-known historical artists, alongside established contemporary artists.
Market Segments and Geography
The impact of the downturn has varied across different market segments and geographical regions. Despite the overall decline, online sales have continued to grow, now representing 18% of turnover, almost double pre-pandemic levels. Contrary to the global trend, the Chinese art market grew by 9% to an estimated $12.2 billion, overtaking the UK as the second-largest market
While the art market is facing significant challenges, there are some signs of resilience. The market remains above pre-pandemic levels, and the continued growth of online sales and the strong performance of the Chinese market offer some positive indicators for the future. However, the overall outlook remains uncertain as the market continues to navigate the post-election economic landscape. The shift in buyer preferences has had a significant impact on the art market in recent years, particularly following the economic uncertainty of the post-pandemic period. Here are some key ways this shift has affected the market:
Focus on Established Artists
Collectors have shown a growing preference for works by older, established artists, viewing them as safer investments during uncertain times. There has been a slight cooling off in demand for works by younger, emerging artists who had benefited from an upswing during the COVID-19 pandemic
Market Adaptations
Auction houses have been lowering estimates, and galleries have become more open to price negotiations to meet buyer expectations. Current conditions are providing opportunities for collectors in the $100,000 to $3 million range, where there are broader offerings and greater room for negotiation. The shift has led to an increased focus on quality and provenance in the market. There's an increased emphasis on contemporary and 20th/21st century art, which comprises the bulk of auction house revenues. Some auction houses are diversifying their offerings to include advisory services, appraisals, and private sales.
Impact on Sales and Prices
There has been a notable slowdown in turnover at the high end of the market. Global auction sales across all fine art categories decreased 27% from 2022 to 2023, with the average price of an artwork sold at auction decreasing by 32%
There's a growing discrepancy between buyers' and sellers' price expectations, leading to a supply-demand mismatch in both primary and secondary markets.
Technological Influence
The shift in buyer preferences has accelerated the adoption of online sales platforms, which have become integral to the art market. The pandemic period saw a rapid rise in interest for NFTs and digital art, attracting a new, tech-savvy audience to the art market. Auction houses have rapidly embraced online platforms, allowing for greater accessibility and a broader reach of potential buyers worldwide. The development of mobile apps has enabled real-time bidding from anywhere, increasing participation and convenience for buyers. Some auction houses are integrating VR and AR technologies to provide immersive previews of items, enhancing the online auction experience. Auction houses are leveraging data analytics to gain insights into buyer behavior, optimize auction strategies, and improve overall decision-making processes. Data analysis is being used to set appropriate starting bids and predict future demand for certain types of items.
AI algorithms are being employed to provide tailored recommendations and customized bidding experiences for clients. Many auction houses have embraced the trend of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and digital art, expanding their offerings to cater to a new generation of tech-savvy collectors. Blockchain for transparency: Some auction houses are adopting blockchain technology to ensure secure and transparent transactions. AI for authentication: Artificial intelligence is being used to assist in the authentication and valuation of artworks and other valuable items. By embracing these trends and innovations, auction houses are not only adapting to the changing market landscape but also actively shaping it. They continue to play a crucial role as market intermediaries, providing valuable insights into current asset values and serving as barometers for broader market trends.
References:
https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2024/09/02/global-turmoil-and-rising-taxes-tilt-art-trade-towards-new-era
https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesbusinesscouncil/2024/05/16/eight-trends-in-the-2024-global-art-market/
https://thewhiteglove.art/resources/economic-trends-and-their-impact-on-the-art-market-in-2024
https://news.artnet.com/market/art-market-reset-riding-the-waves-of-change-2533656
https://www.madeinbed.co.uk/art-business-markets/inflation-and-interest-rates-art-market-allies-or-enemies
https://www.marketplace.org/2024/09/24/the-high-end-art-market-is-tanking-and-thats-a-good-thing/
https://www.privatebank.bankofamerica.com/articles/art-market-fall-update.html
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/18/briefing/art-market-downturn.html
https://designdash.com/2024/07/09/the-contemporary-art-markets-secondary-sales-sector-is-struggling-heres-why/
https://s3.fr-par.scw.cloud/arts/news/what-drives-the-fluctuations-in-the-art-market.html
https://designdash.com/2024/08/04/how-economic-downturns-affect-the-art-market-a-historical-perspective/
https://www.privatebank.bankofamerica.com/articles/art-market-spring-update.html
https://theartmarket.artbasel.com/download/The-Art-Basel-and-UBS-Art-Market-Report-2024.pdf
https://azuramagazine.com/articles/art-market-trends-whats-hot-in-the-art-world
https://www.globalgrowthinsights.com/market-reports/auction-house-market-101094
https://www.generalauction.com/what-are-the-latest-trends-in-the-auction-industry/
https://www.ibisworld.com/united-states/market-research-reports/auction-houses-industry/
https://fastercapital.com/topics/the-role-of-auction-houses-in-the-market.html
https://fiveable.me/art-market-economics/unit-4/auction-house-operations-strategies/study-guide/r0hR3RtvZh9T7ej3
